Mind trap - different lifes of twins - help decode?

[learnerforlife]

[Hidden post: You need 100 posts to see it. You currently have 0.]

[Jlim]

Hi learnerforlife,

What is the location of birth?

[learnerforlife]

[Hidden post: You need 96 posts to see it. You currently have 0.]

[cocodine]

[Hidden post: You need 150 posts to see it. You currently have 0.]

[learnerforlife]

hey cocodine
of course, do so please... i'm hoping to get as many as possible in the forum on this subject.
there are some threads here where twins have been discussed, but only very briefly i think and no real examples of twins being alive with results which charts to use - or not to my knowledge.

this is an interesting subject to me in bazi and hopefully to many others.
i've just been a bit surprised to find out that there is not concensus about whether to change the hour for latter born twin or not and am hoping the experienced readers here will give their comments.

[cocodine]

Hi learnerforlife,

I can agree that each being has a soul but in terms of Qi, since 2 hours is designated for each animal/element (hence, 12 animals for 12 hours, just pointing out in case my explanation is misread)  I, cannot fathom how twins can have different hour pillar.   

Of course, the human Qi in terms of decision making, desires, hatred, needs and etc do make the difference.  Anyway, my 2 sen opinion on the way I think.

cheers,
cc